Start Submission Become a Reviewer

Reading: Isolated Voice Tremor: A Clinical Variant of Essential Tremor or a Distinct Clinical Phenotype?

Download

A- A+
Alt. Display

Viewpoints

Isolated Voice Tremor: A Clinical Variant of Essential Tremor or a Distinct Clinical Phenotype?

Author:

Julie M. Barkmeier-Kraemer

Division of Otolaryngology, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, US
X close

Abstract

Background: The consensus statement by the Task Force on Tremor of the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society excludes individuals with “isolated voice tremor” as a clinical variant of essential tremor (ET). This clinical viewpoint presents a rationale for reconsideration of “isolated voice tremor” as a clinical variant of ET.

Methods: Evidence from the literature was extracted to characterize the clinical phenotype of “isolated voice tremor,” or essential vocal tremor (EVT). Clinical features were extracted from relevant literature available at pubmed.gov using the terms “EVT,” “essential voice tremor,” “primary voice tremor,” and “organic voice tremor.”

Results: The average age of onset in those with EVT was older than 60 years (range 19–84 years), with 75–93% being female. The typical duration of vocal tremor ranged from 1 to 13 years (average 6 years). The distribution of structures exhibiting tremor included the larynx, soft palate, pharynx, and base of tongue in the majority of patients, with some exhibiting tremor of the head and respiratory musculature. The condition of tremor occurred during speech and quiet respiration in 74% of individuals. Rate of tremor ranged from 4 to 10 Hz. Nearly 70% reported onset of vocal tremor prior to upper limb involvement. Family history of tremor was reported in 38–42% of individuals.

Discussion: Those previously classified with EVT demonstrate a similar familial history, rate, tremor classification, and body distribution of ET. EVT is proposed as a clinical variant of ET in the pattern of onset and progression of body distribution from the midline cranial to spinal neural pathways.

How to Cite: Barkmeier-Kraemer JM. Isolated Voice Tremor: A Clinical Variant of Essential Tremor or a Distinct Clinical Phenotype?. Tremor and Other Hyperkinetic Movements. 2020;10. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/tohm.535
14
Views
9
Downloads
  Published on 23 Jan 2020
 Accepted on 26 Nov 2019            Submitted on 07 Oct 2019

Introduction

“What’s in a name? That which we call a rose, by any other name would smell as sweet.” This famous quote spoken by Juliet in William Shakespeare’s play, Romeo and Juliet, asserts that an individual’s name does not adequately capture his or her essence or characteristics. Yet, medical and scientific nomenclature aim to systematically define terms and classification systems that accurately capture the essence and characteristics of individuals, including the presence or absence of familial patterns. Consistent and accurate use of clinical terminologies by healthcare professionals and researchers is critical for purposes of characterizing, classifying, and determining the nature and optimal care of individuals diagnosed with a disease.1 As such, classification systems and clinical terminology are periodically re-evaluated for the purpose of integrating advancements in our understanding of diseases that translate into improved research approaches and healthcare practices. Unfortunately, classification systems that define specific medical terms or classification systems by one medical discipline may not always be adopted or accurately implemented by others. In some cases, discipline-specific consensus publications offer criteria for classification of disorders that reflect each particular discipline’s body of literature and clinical practice standards with differing perspectives. This is the case with essential vocal (or voice) tremor, also known as “isolated voice tremor.” The purpose of this viewpoint is to propose essential vocal tremor (EVT) as a clinical variant of essential tremor (ET) as opposed to a distinct clinical phenotype of “isolated voice tremor.”

Discipline-specific consensus

A recent consensus statement on classification of tremors was published by the Task Force on Tremor by the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society (IPMDS).2 This task force clinically defined ET as an “isolated tremor syndrome of bilateral upper limb action tremor with or without tremor in other locations (e.g., head, voice, lower limbs) and in the absence of other neurological signs like dystonia, ataxia, or parkinsonism for at least 3 years duration.”2 A period of 3 years was selected as the minimum criterion based on the consensus that this time frame allows elucidation of progression of disease associated with eventual onset of other neurological signs such as ataxia, parkinsonism, or dystonia.2 (p.17) For individuals describing duration of symptoms for less than 3 years, the term “indeterminate tremor” is recommended until the criterion of 3 years duration of symptoms is met.2 (p.6) Isolated focal tremors involving the voice, head, orthostatic tremor (frequency > 12 Hz), task- and position-specific tremors, and report of sudden onset or step-wise deterioration are considered exclusion criteria for ET and ET plus. “ET plus” was proposed as a separate or extended classification to include those meeting the definition of ET exhibiting additional soft clinical signs of unclear significance possibly indicative of potential subgroupings.2 As such, those with isolated onset of vocal tremor are no longer classified as a variant of ET unless they develop signs and symptoms commensurate with the new definition.

The most recent consensus related to movement disorders affecting the larynx was published in 2005 by a committee representing the Academy of Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS).3 Although an earlier publication, the statement by this committee drives current standards of practice in the field of otolaryngology for evaluating and treating those with movement disorders affecting the larynx and other head and neck structures. Within this document, a description of clinical features of ET and variants affecting the larynx and other speech and respiratory structures involved in speech production were provided. This committee used the term, “laryngeal essential tremor,” rather than EVT since the larynx is the primary structure associated with voice production during speech. However, clinical features associated with laryngeal ET included observation of vertical oscillation of the larynx (i.e., tremor affecting strap musculature influencing the vertical position of the larynx) as well as tremor affecting articulators (e.g., pharyngeal constrictors, intrinsic laryngeal muscles, tongue, soft palate, jaw, and lips) and respiratory system musculature. This committee also highlighted the fact that tremor affecting the larynx would not be classified as “rest” tremor given that the laryngeal musculature is actively involved in respiratory posturing when it is not otherwise engaged in the activities of phonation and swallowing.410 Differentiation between laryngeal tremor of the essential versus dystonic type was reliant on the task specificity of laryngeal behavior during volitional speech tasks compared to nonvolitional respiration (i.e., tidal breathing). Individuals with essential laryngeal tremor were described to exhibit oscillation of speech structures during both respiration and speech tasks (i.e., non-task specific). Those with a dystonic type of laryngeal tremor would demonstrate oscillation of speech structures during volitional tasks such as sustained phonation or speech production, and potentially exhibit improved signs/symptoms in response to sensory tricks, including placement of the nasoendoscope or application of topical anesthesia.

Unfortunately, no group publishing expert consensus-based documents integrated multi-disciplinary expertise on their panels. Representation of salient expertise across related disciplines beyond the primary sponsoring entity would improve generalizability and accuracy of the final classification system. Consequently, both consensus documents offer limited generalizability and accuracy related to the “isolated voice tremor” phenotype. The AAO-HNS group introduced a term, laryngeal ET that does not sufficiently represent involvement of the extra-laryngeal articulators. Although their intent was to link ET manifesting in the larynx, associated clinical features demonstrate that tremor is not typically restricted to the larynx and can involve the respiratory musculature. As such, reference to laryngeal ET is misleading. The IPMDS relied heavily on a systematic review of the literature to inform their updated classification system distinguishing between clinical phenomenology and etiologies (i.e., Axis I versus Axis II criteria). The new classification system accommodates change in the clinical phenotype of individuals diagnosed with ET. In this way, the new tremor classification system may provide new insights regarding the pathophysiology of focal or isolated forms of tremor that may be distinct from ET or ET plus forms. However, the current classification system of tremor referred to “isolated voice tremor” as a focal tremor in the same way as tremor affecting individual structures such as the jaw or head. However, voice production requires coordination across multiple structures innervated by cranial and spinal nerves. The idea that vocal tremor is focal, or “isolated,” may stem from the focus on acoustic measures as a surrogate to tremor patterns affecting speech structures. The voice is a radiating quasiperiodic and modulated airstream resulting from the coordinated contribution of respiratory and articulatory structures. However, studies of individuals with vocal tremor have not yet linked the affected speech apparatus kinematics to associated voice signal patterns. Although tremor has been observed in respiratory and articulatory structures, the larynx as the sound generator is typically the focus of study in those with vocal tremor. Yet, the literature demonstrates that those with EVT distinctly exhibit tremor across multiple structures coordinated and innervated through bilateral cranial and spinal nerve output.

Clinical features of vocal tremor and EVT

In contrast to the vast literature describing the clinical features and phenotypes of ET and other classifications of tremor, the literature describing vocal tremor does not offer comparable information regarding kinematic measures of speech structure tremor rate, or detailed characteristics of onset and progression of the disorder. More typically, studies describing those with EVT confirm that there is either an associated diagnosis of ET, or no other associated neurological diagnoses with onset of voice symptoms. The systematic description of participant’s duration of disease, family history, duration of vocal tremor, age of onset, activation condition(s), body distribution, and other important information for clinical phenotyping is absent in the majority of literature describing those affected with EVT. Alternatively, these individuals are commonly studied among the same cohort with those exhibiting vocal tremor associated with other neurological disorders, including spasmodic dysphonia. As such, it can be difficult to extract clinical features and phenotypes for those with EVT that distinguish them from other clinical phenotypes of vocal tremor.

Vocal tremor is generally considered a neurogenic voice disorder characterized by modulation of pitch and loudness.1116 Individuals with this disorder report increased effort during speaking and worsening of their vocal tremor during stressful activities that promote anxiety or require more concentration and effort.3,17,18 Most individuals believe vocal tremor to be typical of age-related changes in the voice.19,20 As such, many individuals with vocal tremor may not seek treatment, as suggested by community-based studies of ET21 and general population estimates of those with voice disorders.22,23 Those seeking treatment for vocal tremor frequently have co-occurring neurological diagnoses with the majority having ET followed by dystonia (e.g., spasmodic dysphonia) and other neurodegenerative diseases (e.g., Parkinson’s disease, cerebellar degeneration, and myasthenia gravis).2426

Literature characterizing vocal tremor, in general, describes clinical features of tremor affecting the respiratory system,4,2729 tongue,11,13,29,30 jaw,29,31,32 soft palate,10,29,33,34 and larynx.12,13,1517,29,30,35 Clinical characteristics of vocal tremor are best identified and characterized during sustained phonation of a vowel.11,17,3638 However, judgment of the severity of the vocal tremor should consider the degree of impact on connected speech rather than judgment limited to the sustained phonation condition.11,38 Nasoendoscopic examination enables direct observation of upper airway structures such as the soft palate, base of the tongue, larynx, and pharyngeal walls during respiratory activity as well as during sustained phonation and connected speech-related tasks.29,30 Additional direct observation of the face, lips, jaw, and palpation of the respiratory system can be used to identify other structures of the speech apparatus contributing to the perceived vocal tremor.29 A thorough evaluation enables accurate documentation regarding the presence/absence of tremor across speech structures to determine whether tremor appears postural, kinetic, or dystonic (i.e., task specific).

Methods

To determine clinical characteristics aligned with the recommended classification of tremor for this viewpoint, relevant literature was identified through the pubmed.gov search engine using the terms “essential vocal tremor,” “essential voice tremor,” “primary vocal tremor,” or “organic voice tremor.” Literature published in the English language was reviewed to identify information regarding family history, duration of vocal tremor, age of onset, representation of males and females, body distribution, activation condition(s), frequency of vocal tremor, and associated neurological disorders in those classified as affected with EVT. If available, EVT symptomatology response to alcohol intake was also documented. Publications without clinical phenotype information used to classify participants with EVT were excluded from final descriptive analysis. In addition, clinical phenotype information reported for EVT participants also documented with co-morbidities of dystonia or parkinsonism was excluded from the final descriptive analysis.

Results

Figure 1 illustrates the process of the literature review resulting in the identification of three published studies that met inclusion criteria. A total of 53 references were identified across all four search phrases with 30 unique references describing EVT patient populations. Of the 30 publications on EVT, only three provided clinical phenotype information meeting criteria for characterizing isolated vocal tremor. Table 1 shows the 30 total references reviewed for clinical phenotype characteristics. Table 2 shows the descriptive analysis findings for each of the three studies meeting inclusion criteria. That is, only three out of the total of 30 studies studying EVT-affected populations provided clinical phenotype information including participant family history, duration of vocal tremor, age of onset, male to female representation, body distribution, activation condition(s), vocal tremor frequency rate, alcohol responsiveness, and neurological co-morbidities.3941

Table 1

Total Unique References Reporting on EVT Populations for Review

1. Anand S, Shrivastav R, Wingate JM, Chheda NN. An acoustic-perceptual study of vocal tremor. J Voice 2012;26(6):811 e1–e7. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2012.02.007
2. Aronson AE, Brown JR, Litin EM, Pearson JS. Spastic dysphonia. II. Comparison with essential (voice) tremor and other neurologic and psychogenic dysphonias. J Speech Hear Disord 1968;33(3):219–231. http://dx.doi.org/10.1044/jshd.3303.219
3. Aronson AE, Hartman DE. Adductor spastic dysphonia as a sign of essential (voice) tremor. J Speech Hear Disord 1981;46(1):52–58. http://dx.doi.org/10.1044/jshd.4601.52
4. Barkmeier-Kraemer J, Lato A, Wiley K. Development of a speech treatment program for a client with essential vocal tremor. Semin Speech Lang 2011;32(1):43–57. http://dx.doi.org/10.1055/s-0031-1271974
5. Brown JR, Simonson J. Organic voice tremor. A tremor of phonation. Neurology 1963;13:520–525. http://dx.doi.org/10.1212/WNL.13.6.520
6. Brown JR, Simonson J. Organic voice tremor. Trans Am Neurol Assoc 1962;87:179–180.
7. Busenbark K, Ramig L, Dromey C, Koller WC. Methazolamide for essential voice tremor. Neurology 1996;47(5):1331–1332. http://dx.doi.org/10.1212/WNL.47.5.1331
8. Estes C, Sadoughi B, Coleman R, Sarva H, Mauer E, Sulica L. A prospective crossover trial of botulinum toxin chemodenervation versus injection augmentation for essential voice tremor. Laryngoscope 2018;128(2):437–446. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/lary.26911
9. Gurey LE, Sinclair CF, Blitzer A. A new paradigm for the management of essential vocal tremor with botulinum toxin. Laryngoscope 2013;123(10):2497–2501. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/lary.24073
10. Hachinski VC, Thomsen IV, Buch NH. The nature of primary vocal tremor. Can J Neurol Sci 1975;2(3):195–197. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0317167100020254
11. Hartman DE, Overholt SL, Vishwanat B. A case of vocal cord nodules masking essential (voice) tremor. Arch Otolaryngol 1982;108(1):52–53. http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/archotol.1982.00790490054016
12. Hartman DE, Vishwanat B. Spastic dysphonia and essential (voice) tremor treated with primidone. Arch Otolaryngol 1984;110(6):394–397. http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/archotol.1984.00800320048011
13. Hemmerich AL, Finnegan EM, Hoffman HT. The distribution and severity of tremor in speech structures of persons with vocal tremor. J Voice 2016. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2016.05.004
14. Hertegard S, Granqvist S, Lindestad PA. Botulinum toxin injections for essential voice tremor. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2000;109(2):204–209. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/000348940010900216
15. Ho AL, Choudhri O, Sung CK, DiRenzo EE, Halpern CH. Deep brain stimulation for essential vocal tremor: a technical report. Cureus 2015;7(3):e256.
16. Justicz N, Hapner ER, Josephs JS, Boone BC, Jinnah HA, Johns MM, 3rd. Comparative effectiveness of propranolol and botulinum for the treatment of essential voice tremor. Laryngoscope 2016;126(1):113–117. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/lary.25485
17. Koller W, Graner D, Mlcoch A. Essential voice tremor: treatment with propranolol. Neurology 1985;35(1):106–108. http://dx.doi.org/10.1212/WNL.35.1.106
18. Lederle A, Barkmeier-Kraemer J, Finnegan E. Perception of vocal tremor during sustained phonation compared with sentence context. J Voice 2012;26(5):668 e1–e9. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2011.11.001
19. Lester RA, Barkmeier-Kraemer J, Story BH. Physiologic and acoustic patterns of essential vocal tremor. J Voice 2013;27(4):422–432. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2013.01.002
20. Lowell SY, Kelley RT, Monahan M, Hosbach-Cannon CJ, Colton RH, Mihaila D. The effect of octanoic acid on essential voice tremor: a double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Laryngoscope 2019;129(8):1882–1890. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/lary.27695
21. Massey EW, Paulson GW. Essential vocal tremor: clinical characteristics and response to therapy. South Med J 1985;78(3):316–317. http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/00007611-198503000-00020
22. Nida A, Alston J, Schweinfurth J. Primidone therapy for essential vocal tremor. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2016;142(2):117–121. http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jamaoto.2015.2849
23. Orbelo DM, Duffy JR, Hughes Borst BJ, Ekbom D, Maragos NE. Differences in botulinum toxin dosing between patients with adductor spasmodic dysphonia and essential voice tremor. J Voice 2014;28(1):123–127. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2013.05.008
24. Paige C, Hopewell BL, Gamsarian V, Myers B, Patel P, Garrett CG, et al. Characterizing the normative voice tremor frequency in essential vocal tremor. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2018. http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jamaoto.2018.2566
25. Patel A, Frucht SJ. Isolated vocal tremor as a focal phenotype of essential tremor: a retrospective case review. J Clin Mov Disord 2015;2:1–5. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s40734-015-0016-5
26. Parker LA, Kunduk M, Fink DS, McWhorter A. Reliability of high-speed videoendoscopic ratings of essential voice tremor and adductor spasmodic dysphonia. J Voice 2019;33(1):16–26. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2017.10.009
27. Ravikumar VK, Ho AL, Parker JJ, Erickson-DiRenzo E, Halpern CH. Vocal tremor: novel therapeutic target for deep brain stimulation. Brain Sci 2016;6(4). http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/brainsci6040048
28. Sulica L, Louis ED. Clinical characteristics of essential voice tremor: a study of 34 cases. Laryngoscope 2010;120(3):516–528. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/lary.20702
29. Van Doren M, Faudoa E, Carroll TL. Treatment of patients with vocal fold atrophy and comorbid essential voice tremor: long-term injection augmentation outcomes after successful diagnostic vocal fold injection augmentation. J Voice 2018. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2018.11.004
30. Warrick P, Dromey C, Irish J, Durkin L. The treatment of essential voice tremor with botulinum toxin A: a longitudinal case report. J Voice 2000;14(3):410–421. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0892-1997(00)80086-7

Table 2

Literature Describing Clinical Characteristics of those with EVT, or Isolated Voice Tremor

Reference Population Size Family History Duration of Vocal Tremor Age of Onset Male and Female Representation Body Distribution Activation Condition (Rest vs. Action) Rate Alcohol Responsiveness Other Associated Neurologic Disorders
Patel and Frucht39 19 8 (42%) with family h/o ET and 5 (26%) with vocal tremor specifically 6 years (+/- 4 years) 64 years (+/- 8 years) 89% female Larynx, palatal, and pharyngeal musculature during sustained phonation (no mention of respiratory observations); Head tremor (N = 6), N = 3 had slight action tremor of upper extremities; N = 2 had both head and limb tremor Action (based on presence during phonation) 4–8 Hz via acoustic measures 100% of those who consumed alcohol (N = 11) “Patients were subsequently followed for as little as 6 months and as long as 10 years without the development of dystonia or parkinsonism.” (p 2)
Sulica and Louis40 34 38.2% had a familial history and 58.8% did not 12.7 years (+/-13.4 years) Range of 0.5–20 years 62.9 years (+/- 15 years) Range of 19–84 years 92.6% female 68% experienced onset of vocal tremor prior to upper limb involvement; 74% exhibited laryngeal oscillation during respiration, palate, pharyngeal wall in majority, with 24% exhibiting base of tongue oscillation Action, Kinetic and postural (based on presence during phonation and quiet breathing) 4–10 Hz via laryngeal Electromyography (EMG) 42.9% of those who consumed alcohol essential tremor
Massey and Paulson41 4 of 131 Of the four patients with isolated vocal tremor, all reported a family history for tremor (one exhibited family history only of vocal tremor) 0.67–6 years not reported, although the age range was 37 –59 years at time of evaluation 75% female respiratory; indirect laryngeal examination only was conducted, making body distribution difficult to determine Action (based on presence during phonation) 4–10 Hz via acoustic measures 100% (N = 4) 26 of 131 exhibited vocal tremor with 4 of these as the initial sign; all others met inclusion criteria for essential tremor. From the 26 with vocal tremor, 2 exhibited head, hands, and voice; 5 exhibited head and voice; 14 exhibited hands and voice; 1 exhibited head, voice, and chin

Abbreviations: EVT, Essential Vocal Tremor; ET, Essential Tremor.

Figure 1 

Total Number of References Identified during the PubMed Search Using Each of the Specific Search Phrases. References specific to EVT and those providing adequate clinical phenotype information to meet inclusion criteria for final descriptive analysis are indicated. A total of 30 unique references addressing EVT were evaluated for clinical phenotype characteristics and three references provided the target clinical phenotype information for descriptive analyses.

The average age of onset in those affected with EVT was older than 60 years,39,40 with a larger proportion of those affected being females.3941 The typical duration of vocal tremor symptoms reported at the time of evaluation ranged between 1 and 12.7 years (see Table 1). The distribution of anatomical structures observed with tremor typically involved the larynx in two studies; the study by Massey and Paulson41 utilized an indirect method of viewing the larynx such that identification of upper airway involvement was difficult to accurately determine. In addition, palatal, pharyngeal, and base of tongue involvement was documented in the majority of patients.39,40 The condition of tremor was noted to occur in all individuals during speech context and in 74% of individuals during quiet respiration.40 Measures of rate were reported from acoustic modulation or laryngeal electromyographic measurements and ranged from 4 to 10 Hz for two studies40,41 and 4 to 8 Hz for one study.39 None of these studies directly evaluated respiratory involvement. One study reported that 68% of those diagnosed with EVT reported onset of their vocal tremor prior to upper limb involvement.40 The other two studies solely described those with isolated voice tremor, although a small proportion of those seen also exhibited tremor involving the head (N = 6) and upper extremities (N = 3) as shown in the study conducted by Patel and Frucht.39 A family history of tremor was reported in approximately 38–42%.39,40 Two studies reported improved vocal tremor symptoms in 100% of participants who consumed alcohol,39,41 whereas approximately 43% reported similar benefit among those who consume alcohol in the third study.40

One study that was not included in Table 1 reported outcomes of a thorough prospective assessment of tremor affecting the structures of the speech apparatus in 20 adults diagnosed with mild, moderate, and severe vocal tremor and two adult controls.29 This study did not use the term, EVT, and six individuals from among the cohort were also diagnosed with spasmodic dysphonia. None of the participants were diagnosed with parkinsonism or cerebellar dysfunction. This study was one of the first studies to systematically document the severity level of vocal tremor and associated involvement of speech apparatus structures during sustained phonation. The outcomes of this study showed a pattern of greater perceived severity of vocal tremor associated with wider spread of tremor across oral, pharyngeal (including laryngeal), and respiratory structures. The only speech condition tested in this study was sustained phonation of the vowel, “ee,” such that the condition of tremor during respiratory patterns was not determined. The latter condition would help distinguish between those individuals with dystonic (i.e., task specific) tremor and those with tremor patterns across volitional and nonvolitional conditions. Nonetheless, the findings of this study support the fact that those with vocal tremor do not generally exhibit an isolated laryngeal tremor as those with EVT. Rather, those meeting diagnostic criteria for EVT exhibit greater spread of tremor across the speech apparatus, including the respiratory structures. This was particularly true as the severity of the vocal tremor was rated as worse.

Discussion

In general, the clinical features of EVT include classification as an action tremor involving multiple oral, pharyngeal (including laryngeal), and respiratory structures across volitional (i.e., speech) and nonvolitional (i.e., tidal breathing) conditions. Given that the larynx is neurologically regulated by nonvolitional as well as volitional respiratory functions, it is not surprising that tremor affecting the larynx might also be found in other respiratory structures.42 Overall, both “isolated” and ET-associated forms of vocal tremor demonstrate spread of tremor through the speech apparatus innervated by cranial nerves, although respiratory and strap musculature may also be involved.

EVT as a clinical variant of ET

The revised classification of tremors requires careful documentation of distinct clinical phenotypes. Based on a limited review of literature describing those classified as EVT, improved documentation of clinical phenotyping is needed. Only three of 30 published studies specific to EVT offered adequate clinical characterization to assure accurate classification. Based on the small number of carefully conducted studies documenting characteristics of those with EVT, the majority of affected individuals reported onset of vocal tremor prior to onset of tremor in the upper extremities required for classification as ET. Interestingly, the current classification criteria for ET include those exhibiting spread of tremor along the motor somatotopy of the body from the upper extremities to the neck (i.e., head) and respiratory/articulatory structures. This represents a spread from spinal to cranial (or midline) structures as a more common clinical phenotype. However, nearly 70% of those with EVT were reported by one study to exhibit the opposite spread of tremor beginning in the midline structures (i.e., cranial) to the upper extremities. This suggests a reverse clinical phenotype of tremor in ~1/3 of individuals eventually meeting inclusion criteria for ET originally classified as “isolated voice tremor.” Although further systematic work is needed regarding clinical characteristics of those with EVT, current evidence suggests an action tremor at a rate between 4 and 10 Hz and a similar family history rate as expected for those with ET. The primary distinction of individuals with EVT is the disproportionate representation of females and the direction of tremor spread from cranial to spinal motor somatotopy. Another topic for future consideration is to compare treatment responses between those classified with “isolated voice tremor” and those with ET and vocal tremor. Several published studies that did not meet inclusion criteria for this article provide evidence that those with vocal tremor due to EVT or ET may exhibit similar improvement in voice symptomatology as those with bilateral limb tremor classified as ET in response to pharmaceutical treatment4348 and deep brain stimulation (DBS).4952

Although “isolated voice tremor” may offer a unique clinical phenotype in onset and progression, it appears to be a variant of ET rather than a distinct clinical phenotype. Eventually, ET and EVT may be considered clinical phenotypic variants of tremor in the same way regional variants of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) inform disease prognosis and pathophysiology.53

Notes

1 Citation: JM. Barkmeier-Kraemer. Isolated Voice Tremor: A Clinical Variant of Essential Tremor or a Distinct Clinical Phenotype? Tremor Other Hyperkinet Mov. 2020; 10. doi: 10.7916/tohm.v0.738 

2 Editor: Elan D. Louis, Yale University, USA 

3 Funding: This work is funded by the NIDCD to conduct research on those with essential tremor and vocal tremor (R01DC016838, Physiologic correlates of vocal tremor affecting those with essential tremor, PI: Barkmeier-Kraemer). 

4 Financial Disclosures: None. 

5 Conflict of Interest: The author conducts funded and unfunded research on individuals with vocal tremor relevant to the topic of this viewpoint. 

6 Ethics Statement: Not applicable for this category of article. 

References

  1. Aspden, P, , Corrigan, JM and , Wolcott, J, , Erickson, SM, , eds. Patient safety: achieving a new standard for care. Washington, DC: National Academies Press; 2004. 

  2. Bhatia, KP , Bain, P , Bajaj, N , Elble, RJ , Hallett, M , Louis, ED , et al. Consensus statement on the classification of tremors. From the task force on tremor of the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society. Mov Disord 2018;33(1):75–87. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/mds.2712129193359 

  3. Merati, AL, , Heman-Ackah, YD, , Abaza, M and , Altman, KW, , Sulica, L, , Belamowicz, S, Common movement disorders affecting the larynx: a report from the neurolaryngology committee of the AAO-HNS. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2005;133(5):654–665. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.otohns.2005.05.00316274788 

  4. Koda, J and , Ludlow, CL, An evaluation of laryngeal muscle activation in patients with voice tremor. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1992;107(5):684–696. doi: https://doi.org/10.1177/0194599892107005101437206 

  5. Stella, MH and , England, SJ, Laryngeal muscle response to phasic and tonic upper airway pressure and flow. J Appl Physiol 2001;91(2):905–911. doi: https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.2001.91.2.90511457809 

  6. Berkowitz, RG, , Ryan, MM , Pilowsky, PM, Respiration-related laryngeal electromyography in children with bilateral vocal fold paralysis. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2009;118(11):791–795. doi: https://doi.org/10.1177/00034894091180110819999365 

  7. Samson, N, , Lafond, JR, , Moreau-Bussiere, F , Reix, P, , Praud, JP, Cricothyroid muscle electrical activity during respiration and apneas in lambs. Respir Physiol Neurobiol 2007;155(2):147–155. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resp.2006.04.00816713757 

  8. Sun, QJ, , Berkowitz, RG and , Goodchild, AK, , Pilowsky, PM, Serotonin inputs to inspiratory laryngeal motoneurons in the rat. J Comp Neurol 2002;451(1):91–98. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.1032912209844 

  9. Ryan, S, , McNicholas, WT and , O'Regan, RG, , Nolan, P, Effect of upper airway negative pressure and lung inflation on laryngeal motor unit activity in rabbit. J Appl Physiol 2002;92(1):269–278. doi: https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00413.200111744670 

  10. Cheng, S, , Butler, JE and , Gandevia, SC, , Bilston, LE, Movement of the human upper airway during inspiration with and without inspiratory resistive loading. J Appl Physiol 2011;110(1):69–75. doi: https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00413.201020966195 

  11. Brown, JR and , Simonson, J, Organic voice tremor. A tremor of phonation. Neurology 1963;13:520–525. doi: https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.13.6.52014016001 

  12. Finnegan, EM, , Luschei, ES and , Barkmeier, JM, , Hoffman, HT, Synchrony of laryngeal muscle activity in persons with vocal tremor. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2003;129(3):313–318. doi: https://doi.org/10.1001/archotol.129.3.31312622540 

  13. Gamboa, J , Jimenez-Jimenez, FJ , Nieto, A , Cobeta, I , Vegas, A , Orti-Pareja, M , et al. Acoustic voice analysis in patients with essential tremor. J Voice 1998;12(4):444–452. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0892-1997(98)80053-29988031 

  14. Ludlow, CL, , Bassich, CJ and , Connor, NP, , Coulter, DC, Phonatory characteristics of vocal fold tremor. J Phonetics 1986;14(3–4):509–515. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0095-4470(19)30699-0 

  15. Warrick, P, , Dromey, C and , Irish, J, , Durkin, L, The treatment of essential voice tremor with botulinum toxin A: a longitudinal case report. J Voice 2000;14(3):410–421. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0892-1997(98)80053-211021508 

  16. Warrick, P, , Dromey, C, , Irish, JC and , Durkin, L, , Pakiam, A, , Lang, A, Botulinum toxin for essential tremor of the voice with multiple anatomical sites of tremor: a crossover design study of unilateral versus bilateral injection. Laryngoscope 2000;110(8):1366–1374. doi: https://doi.org/10.1097/00005537-200008000-0002810942143 

  17. Dromey, C, , Warrick, P , Irish, J, The influence of pitch and loudness changes on the acoustics of vocal tremor. J Speech Lang Hear Res 2002;45(5):879–890. doi: https://doi.org/10.1044/1092-4388(2002/071)12381046 

  18. Mendoza, E and , Carballo, G, Vocal tremor and psychological stress. J Voice 1999;13(1):105–112. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0892-1997(00)80086-710223678 

  19. Linville, SE The sound of senescence. J Voice 1996;10(2):190–200. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0892-1997(96)80046-48734394 

  20. Verdonck-de Leeuw, IM and , Mahieu, HF, Vocal aging and the impact on daily life: a longitudinal study. J Voice 2004;18(2):193–202. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2003.10.00215193652 

  21. Louis, ED and , Ferreira, JJ, How common is the most common adult movement disorder? Update on the worldwide prevalence of essential tremor. Mov Disord 2010;25(5):534–541. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/mds.2283820175185 

  22. Cohen, SM Self-reported impact of dysphonia in a primary care population: an epidemiological study. Laryngoscope 2010;120(10):2022–2032. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.2105820830762 

  23. Cohen, SM, , Kim, J, , Roy, N , Asche, C, , Courey, M, Prevalence and causes of dysphonia in a large treatment-seeking population. Laryngoscope 2012;122(2):343–348. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.2242622271658 

  24. Perez, KS, , Ramig, LO and , Smith, ME, , Dromey, C, The Parkinson larynx: tremor and videostroboscopic findings. J Voice 1996;10(4):354–361. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0892-1997(96)80027-08943139 

  25. Wolraich, D, , Vasile Marchis-Crisan, C, , Redding, N , Khella, SL, , Mirza, N, Laryngeal tremor: co-occurrence with other movement disorders. ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec 2010;72(5):291–294. doi: https://doi.org/10.1159/00031703220798566 

  26. Woodson, G Management of neurologic disorders of the larynx. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2008;117(5):317–326. doi: https://doi.org/10.1177/00034894081170050118564527 

  27. Hachinski, VC, , Thomsen, IV , Buch, NH, The nature of primary vocal tremor. Can J Neurol Sci 1975;2(3):195–197. doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/S03171671000202541175102 

  28. Tomoda, H, , Shibasaki, H and , Kuroda, Y, , Shin, T, Voice tremor: dysregulation of voluntary expiratory muscles. Neurology 1987;37(1):117–122. doi: https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.37.1.1173796827 

  29. Hemmerich, AL, , Finnegan, EM , Hoffman, HT, The distribution and severity of tremor in speech structures of persons with vocal tremor. J Voice 2017 31(3):366–377. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2016.05.004 Epub 2016 Jun 8.27289298 

  30. Bove, M, , Daamen, N, , Rosen, C and , Wang, CC, , Sulica, L, , Gartner-Schmidt, J, Development and validation of the vocal tremor scoring system. Laryngoscope 2006;116(9):1662–1667. doi: https://doi.org/10.1097/01.mlg.0000233255.57425.3616955000 

  31. Gonzalez-Alegre, P, , Kelkar, P , Rodnitzky, RL, Isolated high-frequency jaw tremor relieved by botulinum toxin injections. Mov Disord 2006;21(7):1049–1050. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/mds.2087816602105 

  32. Koller, WC, , Busenbark, K , Miner, K, The relationship of essential tremor to other movement disorders: report on 678 patients. Essential Tremor Study Group. Ann Neurol 1994;35(6):717–723. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/ana.4103506138210229 

  33. Krause, E, , Heinen, F , Gurkov, R, Difference in outcome of botulinum toxin treatment of essential palatal tremor in children and adults. Am J Otolaryngol 2010;31(2):91–95. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amjoto.2008.11.00720015723 

  34. Panda, AK, , Kushwaha, S , Kaur, M, Essential palatal tremor with hemifacial and vocal cord tremor. BMJ Case Rep 2013. doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bcr-2013-201327 

  35. Brin MF, FS, , Blitzer, A and , Ramig, LO, , Stewart, C, Movement disorders of the larynx. In: Blitzer, ABM and , Fahn, S, , editors. Neurologic disorders of the larynx. New York, NY: Thieme Medical Publishers, 1992; p. 248–278. 

  36. Ramig LA, ST Comparative measures of vocal tremor and vocal vibrato. J Voice 1987;1(2):162–167. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0892-1997(87)80040-1 

  37. Shipp, T and , Izdebski, K, Current evidence for the existence of laryngeal macrotremor and microtremor. J Forensic Sci 1981;26(3):501–505. doi: https://doi.org/10.1520/JFS11391J7252466 

  38. Lederle, A, , Barkmeier-Kraemer, J , Finnegan, E, Perception of vocal tremor during sustained phonation compared with sentence context. J Voice 2012;26(5):668 e1–e9. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2011.11.001 

  39. Patel, A and , Frucht, SJ, Isolated vocal tremor as a focal phenotype of essential tremor: a retrospective case review. J Clin Mov Disord 2015;2:1–5. doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40734-015-0016-526788337 

  40. Sulica, L and , Louis, ED, Clinical characteristics of essential voice tremor: a study of 34 cases. Laryngoscope 2010;120(3):516–528. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.2070220066728 

  41. Massey, EW and , Paulson, GW, Essential vocal tremor: clinical characteristics and response to therapy. South Med J 1985;78(3):316–317. doi: https://doi.org/10.1097/00007611-198503000-000203975748 

  42. Ludlow, CL Central nervous system control of voice and swallowing. J Clin Neurophysiol 2015;32(4):294–303. doi: https://doi.org/10.1097/WNP.000000000000018626241238 

  43. Guglielmino, G, , Moraes, BT, , Villanova, LC , Padovani, M, , Biase, NG, Comparison of botulinum toxin and propranolol for essential and dystonic vocal tremors. Clinics (Sao Paulo) 2018;73:e87. doi: https://doi.org/10.6061/clinics/2018/e8730020342 

  44. Justicz, N, , Hapner, ER, , Josephs, JS and , Boone, BC, , Jinnah, HA, , Johns, MM 3rd, Comparative effectiveness of propranolol and botulinum for the treatment of essential voice tremor. Laryngoscope 2016;126(1):113–117. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.2548526198384 

  45. Koller, W, , Graner, D , Mlcoch, A, Essential voice tremor: treatment with propranolol. Neurology 1985;35(1):106–108. doi: https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.35.1.1063880874 

  46. Nida, A, , Alston, J , Schweinfurth, J, Primidone therapy for essential vocal tremor. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2016;142(2):117–121. doi: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamaoto.2015.284926660910 

  47. Busenbark, K, , Ramig, L and , Dromey, C, , Koller, WC, Methazolamide for essential voice tremor. Neurology 1996;47(5):1331–1332. doi: https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.47.5.13318909454 

  48. Lowell, SY, , Kelley, RT, , Monahan, M and , Hosbach-Cannon, CJ, , Colton, RH, , Mihaila, D, The effect of octanoic acid on essential voice tremor: a double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Laryngoscope 2019;129(8):1882–1890. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.2769530585335 

  49. Ho, AL, , Choudhri, O, , Sung, CK , DiRenzo, EE, , Halpern, CH, Deep brain stimulation for essential vocal tremor: a technical report. Cureus 2015;7(3):e256. doi: https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.25626180680 

  50. Ravikumar, VK, , Ho, AL, , Parker, JJ , Erickson-DiRenzo, E, , Halpern, CH, Vocal tremor: novel therapeutic target for deep brain stimulation. Brain Sci 2016;6(4), 48 (pp 1–7). doi: https://doi.org/10.3390/brainsci6040048 

  51. Sandstrom, L, , Blomstedt, P , Karlsson, F, Voice tremor response to deep brain stimulation in relation to electrode location in the posterior subthalamic area. World Neurosurg X 2019;3:100024. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wnsx.2019.10002431225518 

  52. Yoon, MS, , Munz, M, , Sataloff, RT , Spiegel, JR, , Heuer, RJ, Vocal tremor reduction with deep brain stimulation. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 1999;72(2–4):241–244. doi: https://doi.org/10.1159/00002973210853084 

  53. Jawdat, O, , Statland, JM, , Barohn, RJ , Katz, JS, , Dimachkie, MM, Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis regional variants (brachial amyotrophic diplegia, leg amyotrophic diplegia, and isolated bulbar amyotrophic lateral sclerosis). Neurol Clin 2015;33(4):775–785. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ncl.2015.07.00326515621 

comments powered by Disqus